I’m starting to question the signing of ECW.


Surely we had the chance to bring in a player of quality in a position we needed added strength?


All we seem to have done is bring in a quota back to play in the reserves, when it looks like Lumb and Edgell are the preferred options to replace Sivo.


If we are not intending to use ECW in the matchday 13 most weeks then what was the point of signing him as we are effectively wasting the quota spot that became free on losing Sivo, when it would have been better used brining in another forward?


It’s looking more and more of an odd decision for me.


IF there was no one of real quality available then don’t use the quota spot for the sake of using it, wait until mid season when some players often become available from overseas 

It’s nearly always the high earners and big signings that are under performing ever week. 
Why does O’Connor get dropped and not the dire Ackers.


Arthur needs to start dropping the likes of Croft, Ackers, Newman, lisone, Frawley, Bentley. 


Keep respecting the same mistakes get the same results. 


We cannot compete with Wigan next week, let’s give the fringe players some game time see what they can do.

Not sure why you’re picking Newman and Bentley out, they both played well yesterday.

Surrendering the Wigan game is just daft. It’s arguably the best fixture to have after last nights game. The team needs stability not chopping and changing 

Didn’t think Newman did anything special last night, scored a try whoo hoo. He’s been dire for too long now.

What did Bentley do last night of note. Abysmally small for Super League level. Drops the ball a lot, penalty machine, makes little yards, no pace,. doesn’t make breaks. in his fourth season here and had about 3 good games ever. 


Players like both the above are why we are where we are, neither would get anywhere near a place in golden era sides and neither would get in any top. 6 super clubs. Our basic quality of player is sub std. the reason year in year we keep failing is fundamentally our squad is low quality, mesmerising to think we are allergy at full capacity.

Harry Newman is the incumbent England Centre, to say he wouldn’t get into a top Six SL side is ridiculous.